top of page
Search

Harness vs Collar: Which is Best for Your Dog?

When it comes to walking your dog, one of the most common questions we hear at Forestside Vets is: “Should I use a harness or a collar?” 


Both options have their pros and cons, and the best choice often depends on your dog’s breed, size, age, and walking style.


In this article, we’ll explore the advantages and disadvantages of harnesses and collars to help you make the right decision for your four-legged friend.


A dog choosing between a collar or a harness
More than a fashion accessory!

The Case for Collars


Pros of Dog Collars

  • Convenience: Collars are easy to slip on and off, making them perfect for quick outings.

  • ID Tags: They are the best place to securely attach your dog’s ID tag, which is a legal requirement in the UK.

  • Training Use: For well-trained dogs that walk calmly on the lead, a collar can be simple and effective.


Cons of Dog Collars

  • Neck Pressure: Collars can put strain on your dog’s throat, especially if they pull on the lead.

  • Injury Risk: Dogs with delicate necks (such as toy breeds or dogs with tracheal issues) may suffer from coughing, choking, or injury when wearing collars during walks.

  • Not Ideal for Pullers: Stronger or excitable dogs may lunge forward, which could cause discomfort or injury.


The Case for Harnesses


Pros of Dog Harnesses

  • Even Pressure Distribution: Harnesses spread pressure across your dog’s chest and shoulders, protecting the neck.

  • Better Control: Especially helpful for larger breeds or energetic dogs who tend to pull.

  • Safety: A well-fitted harness makes it harder for a dog to slip out compared to a collar.

  • Training Support: Some no-pull harnesses help discourage pulling, making walks more enjoyable.


Cons of Dog Harnesses

  • Fitting Required: Getting the right size and fit is essential; otherwise, a harness can cause rubbing or restrict movement.

  • Less Convenient: Harnesses take more time to put on and take off than collars.

  • Not Ideal for Continuous Wear: Unlike collars, harnesses are not suitable for holding ID tags 24/7.


Which Should You Choose for Your Dog?


  • Small or toy breeds: A harness is often the safer choice, reducing pressure on the neck.

  • Large or strong dogs: Harnesses provide better control, especially during training.

  • Well-trained dogs: A collar may be enough for calm, controlled walks.

  • Dogs with respiratory or neck issues: Always opt for a harness.


Final Thoughts from Forestside Vets


Both collars and harnesses have their place in your dog’s life. Many owners choose to use a collar for ID tags and a harness for daily walks - combining the benefits of both.

At Forestside Vets, we’re always happy to help you decide what’s best for your dog’s comfort, health, and safety. If you’re unsure, book a consultation with our veterinary team -

we can assess your dog’s needs and advise on the most suitable option.

 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page